sirocco-rc on DeviantArthttps://www.deviantart.com/sirocco-rc/art/Group-Declined-Image-Updated-174243801sirocco-rc

Deviation Actions

Daily Deviation

Daily Deviation

September 10, 2010
Group-Declined Image"Updated" by =sirocco-rcis simply an excellent idea- a way to get some feedback on why a group declined your image. It lessens the amount of time that admin have to write back and the member gets at least a general idea of why it wasn't accepted. I think many group admin and members would love to see this implemented!
Suggested by =Flame-of-the-Phoenix

I really like this idea because as the admin of a group that sometimes rejects works (and all of them so far has been the same reason) it can get rather repetitive typing out and sending the same message to multiple deviants. This will make work for group admins much easier and faster.
Suggested by *SilverBrumbyThowra


Also suggested by *CACecil, =ikai-zixie and ~lavalampkap

[dA related > deviantART Suggestions > Visual Suggestions]
Featured by GinkgoWerkstatt
sirocco-rc's avatar

Group-Declined Image'Updated'

By
Published:
19.5K Views

Description

:star::star:Update: Thank you all for the feedback, was very helpful, so here's an update of my previous deviation about 'Groups - Declined Images'.
Added a drop down menu with reasons written on buttons.

Group Founders and Moderators please let me know in a comment/message/note, if this suggestion will work for you too, where you would like this drop down menu be placed, which are for your Group the main reasons to decline a member's submission and/or any other suggestion you may have. Thank you :heart:
:iconthreedotsplz::iconthreedotsplz::iconthreedotsplz::iconthreedotsplz::iconthreedotsplz::iconthreedotsplz::iconthreedotsplz:

:star:Reason:

Many times I read in Groups' comments their members complaining for not given any reason, why their work was declined.
Happened to me and I had to send 2 messages to get the reply that was submitted in a wrong folder. I must addmit that I felt a bit uncomfortable to bother the moderators there because of the amount of images they have to check and all the other stuff they do...
So, I thought that it would be a nice way for this problem to be solved, if dA could add on those buttons few more words that will explain the reason why a member's submission was declined. :eager:
:iconthreedotsplz::iconthreedotsplz::iconthreedotsplz::iconthreedotsplz::iconthreedotsplz::iconthreedotsplz::iconthreedotsplz:
Fella by :iconfella:
:iconthreedotsplz::iconthreedotsplz::iconthreedotsplz::iconthreedotsplz::iconthreedotsplz::iconthreedotsplz::iconthreedotsplz:
:heart: Would love to read your opinion about this, so please let me know what you think, and if this is something you'd like to see!
:iconthreedotsplz::iconthreedotsplz::iconthreedotsplz::iconthreedotsplz::iconthreedotsplz::iconthreedotsplz::iconthreedotsplz:
:star: Forum Thread: [link]

:heart: Featured here: [link] by *paperdragon1967
:iconthreedotsplz::iconthreedotsplz::iconthreedotsplz::iconthreedotsplz::iconthreedotsplz::iconthreedotsplz::iconthreedotsplz:
:star::star:Update 2:
~ Suggestions for additional reasons ~

:bulletgreen:=gppr suggested "Incomplete credits"
:bulletgreen:~xXVampireDreamerXx suggested "Previously declined", "WIP"(incompleted work)
She also suggests that something like this can be used for contests or theme of the month activities as well.
:bulletgreen:=astralstonekeeper suggested "Not enough credit"
:bulletgreen:=gppr suggested "Incomplete credits"
:bulletgreen:~medreaming suggested "Does not meet quality standards", "Does not follow rules"
:bulletgreen:=MarcoMaxwell suggested "Add it to X folder", "Please, read the rules again"
:bulletgreen:*KassidiKeys suggested "Use of copyrighted materials without permission/copyright infringement"
:bulletgreen:=TheBourgyman wrote "The only thing I'd add to this is an option to write custom reasons, so groups with specifics rules should be able to give specific reasons for declining something, and not just select the generic ones".
:iconthreedotsplz::iconthreedotsplz::iconthreedotsplz::iconthreedotsplz::iconthreedotsplz::iconthreedotsplz::iconthreedotsplz:
:star: Edit: I'm truly excited and thankful for this DD!

Huge 'Thanks' to =Flame-of-the-Phoenix, *SilverBrumbyThowra, *CACecil, =ikai-zixie and ~lavalampkap for suggesting it and ^ginkgografix for make it happen! :hug:

Thank you ALL for your kind comments and favs! :heart:
:iconthreedotsplz::iconthreedotsplz::iconthreedotsplz::iconthreedotsplz::iconthreedotsplz::iconthreedotsplz::iconthreedotsplz:
Image size
1199x959px 394.23 KB
© 2010 - 2024 sirocco-rc
Comments538
Join the community to add your comment. Already a deviant? Log In
The-Average-Alex's avatar
:sushi: We need this :/
like now.xD :sushi: